The following will compare previous discussion by the task force and how it fits with the proposed conceptual framework proposed by Elias.
| Groups of data as identified in the ToS & EULA Meeting, 26 Nov 2008) | Response |
|---|---|
| data I directly provided | This falls under the "self" dimension |
| data people added directly to data I provided | This falls under "group/metadata" |
| all of the user generated data on a site | The falls under the "global" dimension |
| data generated by the site | ?? |
| Questions as identified in the ToS & EULA Meeting, 11 Feb 2009 | Response |
|---|---|
| Do I need to create a new identity for this site, or can I use an existing one? | Data: This relates to the self class Portability: This relates to the add dimension |
| Do I need to import information into this product, or can I have it refer to information that's stored someplace else? | Data: This relates to the self classPortability: This relates to the add dimension |
| Can this site accept updates that I make on other sites? | Data: This relates to the self classPortability: This relates to the modify dimension |
| If I update information, is that information stored on this site or can I ask this service to store it elsewhere? | Portability: This relates to the modify dimension |
| Can I have other sites use the information that I've entered here? | Portability: This relates to the view dimension |
| Can I download a copy of everything I've provided to this service? | Portability: This relates to the view dimension |
| Can I download information that others have provided to the service? | Data: This relates to the group dimension Portability: This relates to the view dimension |
| Will this site delete my account and all associated data upon my request? | Portability: This relates to the remove dimension |
| If I am banned, can I still download my data? | Portability: This relates to the view dimension |
| Can I delegate permissions to other agents or people? | Portability: This relates to the agent dimension |
| Can I restrict the flow of my data (ie, control only aspects of a data profile to flow to another system) | Portability: This relates to the view dimension, although it should be explicitly classified |
| Questions as identified for content in the ToS & EULA Meeting, 10 Mar 2009 | response |
|---|---|
| Can I have other products use the information I've stored here? | Portability: relates to the view dimension |
| Is the structure available, visible, and documented? | Portability: relates to the view dimension |
| What are the terms for access to the data? | This is a characteristic of portability - should be added in |
| Can this product accept updates I've made using other products? | Portability: relates to the write dimension |
| Can I export a copy of everything I've done on this site? | Portability: relates to the view dimension |
| Can I download things that other people have provided? | Data: This relates to the group dimension Portability: This relates to the view dimension |
| Can I use this product to update information on another product? | Portability: This relates to the modify |
| Will this product let me delete what I've provided? | Portability: This relates to the remove dimension |
| Can I decide who is allowed to download what I provide? | Portability: This relates to the agent dimension |